Video Exclusives

Hankook Motorsport season review 2017


Engineers give an insight into the amass of tire design and development challenges thrown up during more than 320 races completed last season

Click here to watch the video

Novel sensor technologies


The Centre for Process Innovation (CPI) and Silent Sensors are developing tire sensors using additive manufacturing and novel materials. As part of this, Silent Sensors will make IoT components using a roll-to-roll process pioneered by CPI, which can be incorporated into tires

Click here to watch the video

With the advent of hybrid and electric vehicles, will traditional tires be succeeded by tall, narrower designs?

Industry Opinion

« back to blog listings

Cutting corners

In my last column I discussed what would be required to ‘fully test a tire’ and what useful information could come from this endeavor. However, every thought has an equal and opposite thought, which raises the questions: what is the minimum amount of testing required to generate useful results, and how can those results be used?

Tire testing will always be a very expensive pastime, so any cost-cutting ideas are broadly welcomed. This formed the basis of my ongoing PhD to develop a cost-effective and complete flat-track test procedure called GS2MF. The objective is to obtain all the required data using the least possible rig time, thereby minimizing costs. However, even when using GS2MF at least a few hours of flat-track time are required to obtain one complete data set used to build a fully populated Magic Formula 6.1 handling model with pressure sensitivity. That’s still a costly chunk of test time, so what if that’s not feasible? Can you semi-populate a tire model with a reduced data set to save money? Would that still be useful?

The law of diminishing returns can be applied here, whereby the more testing you do the less useful each additional piece of data is. So, halving the amount of testing will not usually halve the value of the data. With that in mind, in place of a full test procedure such as GS2MF, very minimal testing could be carried out and still give very useful results.

Conducting simple steering sweeps at around five loads will provide adequate data pertaining to what are arguably the most important tire performance attributes, namely cornering stiffness, aligning stiffness and peak grip, as well as load sensitivities. Add in extra sweeps at the middle load and at three camber angles, then again at three inflation pressures, and a reasonable approximation of the tire’s complete steering characteristics can be established from just 11 test sweeps.

Furthermore, statistical approaches exist that can estimate a tire’s longitudinal and combined performance from just the steering data. If there is budget for extra testing, the same 11 sweeps could be run longitudinally to measure the pure braking and driving performance. Then one can use a friction ellipse assumption to fill in the gaps and estimate the combined performance (steering while braking or accelerating).

With only this minimal data set, a perfectly reasonable tire model could be parameterized and used successfully in full-vehicle simulations.

A similar approach could be used to obtain the tire’s ride performance. Extensive footprint tests can be conducted very cheaply using a hydraulic press with a load cell and either carbon paper or normal paper and a hot wire. With this it is possible to build up a decent data set of footprint sizes and shapes comprising many different loads, camber angles and inflation pressures, without spending heavily.

This data is very important and fundamental to the parameterization of the FTire, CDTire or RMOD-K ride models, among others, where the mantra of ‘Get the footprint right and the rest will follow’ is often adhered to.

After this, fitting a regulator valve to the hydraulic press along with a distance sensor will enable measurement of the tire’s vertical force versus displacement. Using this system, an extensive data set of static vertical stiffnesses can be obtained cheaply, and this forms the basis for the next step of the ride model parameterization. Once this is complete, some testing on a drum rig will be required to gather dynamic cleat test data necessary to finish off the ride model. As with the handling model, this will not be a perfect ride model but will be perfectly reasonable and could be used effectively in full-vehicle simulations to generate valuable vehicle-level results.

Tire testing will always be expensive, but there are ways the costs can be minimized and useful results still obtained. Even with a substantial test budget, depending on the application it is often more beneficial to conduct a reduced test over a wide range of tires than an exhaustive test on just a few. This is due to the fact there are usually substantial variations between tire constructions, even within similar types and sizes of tires. An exploratory exercise such as the one described here could be informative, even for the established tire tester. I’d welcome your feedback!

July 12, 2017



There are currently no comments.

If you would like to post a comment about this blog, please click here.

Your email address:

Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Web Exclusives

Drivers in Europe reveal they do not change their tires to suit conditions
A study conducted by Nokian Tyres has shown that a significant amount of European motorists drive on unsuitable tires for the conditions
Read Now

Futures market
Goodyear’s chief technology officer, Chris Helsel, discusses the emerging requirements for future autonomous vehicle tires
Read Now

Motorsport design influences
Torsten Ideker, a head engineer at the Hankook Tire European Technical Center, explains how tire technologies derived through motorsport have been applied in the company’s ultra-high performance road car rubber
Read Now

Winter test partnership
Italian tire giant Pirelli has chosen Arctic Falls as the location for its newest test base
Read Now

Data directory: an assessment of the truck tire market
Smithers Rapra predicts intermediate level growth in demand for truck tires globally, even as the market continues to evolve and diversify
Read Now

Supplier Spotlight

Supplier SpotlightWe are building a list of leading suppliers covering all aspects of the tire industry. Want to see your company included? Contact for more details.

Submit your industry opinion

Industry BlogDo you have an opinion you'd like to share with the tire technology community? We'd like to hear your views and opinions on the leading issues shaping the industry. Share your comments by sending up to 500 words to

Submit Your Recruitment Ad

Recruitment AdTo send us your recruitment advertising or to receive information on placing a banner please email