Video Exclusives


Inside Arctic Falls' Indoor Flex facility

Sentury

Raw footage taken in the new test hall at the Swedish proving ground, scheduled to open later this month

Click here to watch the video


Michelin launches recycling campaign

Sentury

The French tire maker has unveiled its ambitious future recycling strategy to ensure that by 2048, all of its tires are manufactured using 80% sustainable materials, and 100% of all end-of-life tires are recycled.

Click here to watch the video


A glimpse at Nokian's new test facility

Sentury

A rendering of the tire maker's new technology center in Spain shows what the facility will look like when it is complete in 2019. Find out more in the March 2018 issue (p60) of TTI

Click here to watch the video


In what year did Bridgestone officially launch its first run-flat tire?

Industry Opinion

« back to blog listings

A new approach

A question was raised recently in an exciting automotive budgeting meeting: “Why don’t you fully test every characteristic of one tire, then use that to learn all the tire performance dependencies?”

I can see the logic behind this from a budgeting perspective as it could avoid the need for testing multiple tires in the same way. It also makes sense if you are testing something that is reasonably linear and predictable in its nature. However, tires are rarely predictable, hence the approach raises two questions: firstly, what exactly is required to ‘fully’ test a tire?; and second, can you learn all the tire performance interaction from one construction?

Tackling the first question is a fairly simple matter of arithmetic. Starting with flat-track work, a lengthy set of testing will be required to obtain a dense collection of handling and transient data over a wide range of load cases. Then, drum testing could be used to obtain high- and low-frequency ride and impact data.

Up to this point, we are only testing on sandpaper, so some real road surface testing will be required; this could be via a trailer, a wheel-force transducer car, or alternatively Camber Ridge could be used. An extension of this will need to cover wet surface testing over a range of water depths as well as hydroplaning tests. Depending on the nature of the tire, winter weather and off-road tests may also need to be included.

All together, this will give us our fundamental force and moment performance and dependencies that relate to the handling and ride performance of a vehicle. Extensive ancillary testing will then be needed to quantify rolling resistance, noise, wear, durability, and anything I may have overlooked. Overall, this will be a massive schedule of tests – and hence costly to commission.

With this complete, it would be possible to analyze the data and obtain a good set of tire performance dependencies for that particular tire. These dependencies refer to how different performance attributes of a tire interact with one another and then change based on other inputs. Cornering stiffness, for example, typically increases with load up to a point, after which it levels off and begins to decrease with load. By thoroughly testing a tire, it is possible to build up an understanding of all the dependencies.

This brings us to question two – and with it, comes a problem: while the general nature of these dependencies is reasonably consistent (at least within a particular tire type such as PCR, NASCAR, TBR, etc), the magnitude of these interactions changes considerably between constructions. We can’t be sure that dependencies established from testing one tire will hold true for another.

To investigate this, we must repeat this set of testing over a range of tires. But what range? Do we test across a range of section widths, diameters, tread patterns? The answer, of course, is that we’ll have to test across a complete range of every type of tire – and both program timing and cost restrictions immediately rule this out as a viable option. Furthermore, with the relentless march of vehicle development in an OEM, the tire itself may well be null and void by the time this exhaustive set of tests are complete.

That’s not to say that the results are not useful. One complete set of tire interaction data may well be very useful for certain engineering problems, such as in an academic or fundamental research setting. Racing could be another example where you are usually constrained to a very limited choice of tires. However, it’s less useful in an automotive setting, where we work with hundreds of different tire constructions. Therefore, unless you have a special-case vehicle that you know will only ever run on one or two particular tire types, I would argue that for most applications a highly detailed data set of just one tire is far less useful than a limited data set encompassing a wide range of tires.

As I discussed in my October 2016 column (goo.gl/3hmvjq), traditionally all thermal tire performance dependencies have been largely ignored in the automotive sector, in favor of acquiring simpler models of many different tires. It’s only comparatively recently that the accuracy of full vehicle simulations has improved to the point where ignoring the tire’s thermal properties is no longer adequate. As a result, interest in delivering high-fidelity thermal tire models in large numbers is starting to take off.

May 17, 2017
 

 

Comments:

There are currently no comments.

If you would like to post a comment about this blog, please click here.
RECEIVE THE
LATEST NEWS


Your email address:



Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Web Exclusives

Arctic Falls' Indoor Flex facility now operational
The grand opening of Arctic Falls' new Indoor Flex facility, which will offer new tire and vehicle testing possibilities, is scheduled for the end of June.
Read Now

ETRMA consolidates used tire management data for 2016
Data gathered by the ETRMA from 32 countries in the EU shows that 94% of used tires in 2016 were collected and treated
Read Now

BKT in R&D tie-up with Kultevat
Indian tire giant BKT has entered into a research and development partnership with US biotechnology firm Kultevat to further the use of TKS rubber as a substitute for natural rubber
Read Now

Completely truckworthy
Bridgestone America's director for commercial tire development, Mitchel Kritzell, gives an update on the SuperTruck II program
Read Now

Q&A: Sam Visaisouk, CEO, Tyromer
The Retread Tire Association (RTA) speaks with Tyromer CEO, Sam Visaisouk, about the testing of its new tire-derived polymer recycled rubber product in truck and passenger car tires
Read Now


Supplier Spotlight

Supplier SpotlightWe are building a list of leading suppliers covering all aspects of the tire industry. Want to see your company included? Contact olivia.campbell@ukimediaevents.com for more details.

Submit your industry opinion

Industry BlogDo you have an opinion you'd like to share with the tire technology community? We'd like to hear your views and opinions on the leading issues shaping the industry. Share your comments by sending up to 500 words to rachel.evans@ukimediaevents.com

Submit Your Recruitment Ad

Recruitment AdTo send us your recruitment advertising or to receive information on placing a banner please email olivia.campbell@ukimediaevents.com