Video Exclusives


Inside Nexen's Changnyeong plant

Sentury

Visit the highly automated facility in South Korea, outfitted with the most advanced production technologies and systems.

Click here to watch the video


Nokian tire testing

Sentury

Indoor analysis underway at the Nokia R&D facility​

Click here to watch the video


Do you feel you spend too much time acquiring, retrieving and handling data than you do analyzing and interpreting it?

Industry Opinion

« back to blog listings

Clever concepts

Symmetry in various forms occurs in nature and in man-made products. It permeates disciplines ranging from the visual arts and music to biology and the physical sciences. Tires themselves are rotationally symmetric bodies of revolution. Birds, butterflies and human beings possess so-called bilateral symmetry dividing their shapes into left and right halves that are mirror images of one another – although internal organs are usually arranged asymmetrically. Bilateral symmetry is easily recognized and is thought to have evolved in animals because it conferred advantageous movement – known as ‘directed locomotion’ with the potential for streamlining. Most automobiles, airplanes and ships are also outwardly symmetric about their vehicle pitch plane.

Tire tread patterns can exhibit various types of symmetry depending on the product line. The most important class, known as combined point and rotational symmetry, is used on the vast majority of car, truck and SUV tires. Importantly, tires with tread patterns featuring this two-fold symmetry can be mounted in multiple ways on a vehicle (left or right; front or rear) – a convenience preferred by most consumers. Geometrically, if the tire tread pattern remains invariant after a 180° rotation about a fixed point, the pattern is both point and rotationally symmetric. Some everyday non-automotive objects also possess this dual symmetry, including the face cards in a deck of cards. In other words, like most tread patterns, these cards remain the same when turned upside down.

The two-dimensional footprint of a directional tire exhibits so-called line or mirror symmetry – the planar analog of bilateral symmetry. Directional tread patterns, often used on high-performance tires, feature V-shaped ribs and grooves symmetrically disposed shoulder-to-shoulder about the centerline of the tread. Such imagery is characteristic of line symmetry; it infers that each half of a 2D pattern is a reflection of the other. Directional tires with their striking tread patterns are designed to roll one way only, and because of this limitation remain niche products in the automotive market. The medial line of a tire cross-section also exhibits mirror symmetry.

Asymmetric tire tread patterns possess no point, rotational or mirror symmetry and have a limited, but growing, market-driven appeal. The outboard portion of such treads is generally ‘blockier’ to enhance dry cornering, while the inboard region features smaller blocks with grooves and sipes that promote wet traction. Such tires are nominally side-bound – that is, designed to operate on either the left- or right-hand side of a vehicle. The Michelin XAS was the first tire (1965) to purposefully feature tread pattern asymmetry and the first production tire to operate at 130mph (210km/h). Interestingly, the locomotion pattern of the human foot served as the inspiration for the design of the XAS.

In contrast, certain asymmetries known as conicity and ply steer, among others, unavoidably occur in radial tire lateral force behavior. These inherent offsets arise due to manufacturing imprecision and the stacking sequence and orientations of the plies, respectively. These side forces perpendicular to the wheel plane are negligibly small in bias ply tires and usually dismissed as non-issues. In radial constructions, these steering-like forces exist even at zero slip and camber angles. Ply steer, or pseudo-slip, mainly results in vehicle ‘dog tracking’ while conicity, or pseudocamber, produces torque at the steering wheel – known as ‘pull’. Fortunately, ply steer is a deterministic variable that can be determined at the design stage of tire development, while conicity is a random factory variable that is measured post-production using a tire uniformity machine.

Asymmetry can be purposefully exploited in some tire constructions for improved tire-vehicle behavior. For example, steel belts have been intentionally positioned slightly off-center during tire assembly to induce a consistently positive or negative bias in conicity values; similar results can be achieved by making tread depths slightly deeper on one shoulder than the other. These unsymmetrical features allow for balanced positioning of such tires on vehicle front axles during auto assembly operations, which mitigate steering wheel pull while driving. Furthermore, the patent literature dealing with asymmetrical tire constructions is replete with concepts never commercialized.

After spending portions of my career trying to understand, eliminate or control such nuanced tire design concepts involving symmetry and asymmetry, many of my past efforts could prove irrelevant in a future world of autonomous vehicles lacking discerning drivers.

 

Comments:

There are currently no comments.

If you would like to post a comment about this blog, please click here.
RECEIVE THE
LATEST NEWS


Your email address:



Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Read Latest Issue

Web Exclusives

Bridgestone Americas and Versalis in partnership
The two companies have revealed their plans to develop a technology package with the aim of commercializing guayule
Read Now

Yokohama launches revolutionary concept tire
Incorporating new mixing technology, the BluEarth-air EF21 is rated AAA for rolling resistance and an A for wet grip – the highest graded on the market according to the Japanese tire label
Read Now

Nokian unveils images of new Spain facility
More conceptual renderings have been released showing the layout of the new 300ha facility, currently being built south of the Spanish capital of Madrid
Read Now

Snow Academy project
Luleå University of Technology initiates project to develop methods of measuring snow quality in order to improve preparation of test tracks  
Read Now

Drivers in Europe reveal they do not change their tires to suit conditions
A study conducted by Nokian Tyres has shown that a significant amount of European motorists drive on unsuitable tires for the conditions
Read Now


Supplier Spotlight

Supplier SpotlightWe are building a list of leading suppliers covering all aspects of the tire industry. Want to see your company included? Contact olivia.campbell@ukimediaevents.com for more details.

Submit your industry opinion

Industry BlogDo you have an opinion you'd like to share with the tire technology community? We'd like to hear your views and opinions on the leading issues shaping the industry. Share your comments by sending up to 500 words to rachel.evans@ukimediaevents.com

Submit Your Recruitment Ad

Recruitment AdTo send us your recruitment advertising or to receive information on placing a banner please email olivia.campbell@ukimediaevents.com